DanArmak comments on Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality discussion thread, part 15, chapter 84 - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (1221)
In the first place, I realise that you're probably going for an understatement, but I think it's worth noting that Rowling's world-building, in terms of thinking through consequences and implications, is actually atrocious rather than merely inferior. I'll never forget the moment when I realised that DISINTEGRATING LIVE KITTENS is standard spell practice for schoolchildren in the Potterverse, and no-one bats an eyelid. I sometimes ponder whether Rowling herself places an unnaturally low value on any form of life that can't speak a human language, or whether the themes evoked in the last books (that wizards are overdue to pay for their appalling record on non-human rights) are deliberately woven into the Potterverse at an extremely deep level.
That aside, could you give some examples of what you would consider such influences? Given that senior wizards in canon need to have guns explained to them, and that Muggle expert Arthur Weasley struggles to even pronounce "electricity", wizard obliviousness to Muggle society would seem to run so deep that I struggle to imagine one much influencing the other.
Would wizards would react differently to disintegration of live snake hatchlings?
Probably not - Parseltongue is an extremely rare gift.
I specify speaking a human language, incidentally, because mandrakes act like humans to a limited but recognisable extent (they throw tantrums when young, become moody and secretive as teenagers, and attempt to move into each other's pots as young adults), but are still chopped up and used as potion reagents as soon as they achieve maturity. On the other hand, centaurs and goblins are at least recognised as intelligent beings with their own thoughts and feelings to be trampled over.
For those who haven't been keeping up with Eliezer's favorites list on ffnet: Mandragora.
Ooooh, and Tied for Last!
(well, that's just a Riddle/Granger ship fic, but very well done, WITHOUT time travel.)
Because the goblins have got a nation-level army, and everyone's gold in their vaults, and possession is nine points of the law and all of it in case of war. I don't know what the centaurs have, not having read that part of canon, but I predict they too are respected because they are feared.
Hell, would they react differently to disintegration of elves? For that matter, a good percentage of them were okay with mass murder of humans.
Yes. Elves are valuable and useful - recall Lucius nearly had a stroke when he realized he lost his House Elf. It'd be like casually shooting your stable's prime stallion.
Clearly you don't kill your own elves. You do it to somebody you don't like.
They might sue you for destruction of valuable property.
For that matter, a good percentage of humans have been OK with mass murder of humans.
The whole discussion is not very well grounded. Why make a big deal out of kittens but not of chickens etc?