Swimmy comments on [SEQ RERUN] My Childhood Role Model - Less Wrong

1 Post author: MinibearRex 15 May 2012 01:23AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (11)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Swimmy 15 May 2012 06:39:42PM 0 points [-]

You're correct, of course, but I don't think "village idiot" traditionally refers to severly mentally disabled people. Usually it means a person in a group known for being a simpleton. Users on LW with many posts and extremely negative karma scores might be a better reference group.

Comment author: Desrtopa 15 May 2012 08:19:41PM *  1 point [-]

I always think of "village idiot" as referring to a village's most notoriously witless person (or hyperbolically comparing someone to one.) Out of a village of 10,000 or so, statistically you'd expect the dumbest person to have an IQ around the mid forties.

Comment author: JoshuaZ 15 May 2012 08:35:49PM 0 points [-]

10,000 is a very large number for a village. In order for this sort of analogy to make sense, one should be in the stereotypical village with about one of everything, and probably not many more people than Dunbar's number. So maybe 200-500 people.

Comment author: Desrtopa 15 May 2012 08:44:02PM 0 points [-]

I live in a village with a population of about 25,000. Villages vary considerably in size, but villages with populations of much larger than 10,000 are far from unusual.

Comment author: JoshuaZ 15 May 2012 08:46:18PM 1 point [-]

There may be connotation issues here. The connotations to me of the phrase "the village idiot" are that one can refer to the fellow as that and everyone will know who one is talking about as one would for "the village doctor" or something similar. Hence my invocation of Dunbar's number.

Comment author: Desrtopa 15 May 2012 09:51:52PM 3 points [-]

In that case, the least intelligent person in the village would almost certainly be significantly smarter than a gorilla, but I think that any chart which puts a very smart humans and a very stupid human almost right next to each other, and a chimp way off to the left, seriously overestimates the distance between humans and other primates relative to the difference between smart and dumb humans.

There was an interesting article which I believe was linked to on Less Wrong at some point, although I can no longer find it, where a professor talked about his time teaching remedial classes for extremely underperforming high schoolers. He found that his entire upbringing and education had effectively isolated him from really stupid people, and left him without a proper sense of just how dumb people can get without being classified as non functional. The students he was trying to teach were not merely unable to perform basic middle school level math, they were unable to grasp the idea that the school was trying to test their math abilities. To them, it was as if someone on high had just arbitrarily decided to ask what the value of A was, and despite his best efforts he couldn't get them to comprehend why it would make a difference whether they were actually able to figure out the answers to the questions or just managed to pick the correct multiple choice options by luck. They essentially lived in a world where, beyond the basic tribal politics and animal-chasing physics for which our brains are optimized, practically everything was opaque and inexplicable.

There may be a very significant intelligence gap between a mildly retarded person and a dog, which can't even pass a mirror test, but the gap between them and a chimp is not that great. It took tens of thousands of years past the development of intellectually modern humans for us to accumulate sufficient developments of culture to start doing more than mildly better than chimps.

Comment author: gwern 15 May 2012 11:34:22PM 3 points [-]

I haven't seen that link before (although it sounds interesting) and I can't find it searching for reasonable terms. It reminds me of quotes I posted from Yvain about Haiti.