Wei_Dai comments on Building toward a Friendly AI team - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (95)
Aren't Turing and von Neumann (surely they invented "computers" as much as anyone) counterexamples to your thesis?
No, not if you actually read into the history.
Turing published some conceptual math papers that would eventually get the field of computability and thus computer science started, but by no means did he invent the computer.
Computer evolution was already well under way when Turing published his paper on computability introducing Turing Machines in 1936.
The early British programmable digital computer, the Colossus, was developed by colleagues/contemporaries of Turing, but Turing was not involved, and at the time his abstract Turing Machine concept was not viewed as important:
Colossus was designed by the engineer Tommy Flowers.
The first Turing complete computer was the Z3, developed in germany by the engineer Konrad Zuse. Zuse is unlikely to have even heard of Turing, and the Z3 wasn't proven Turing Complete until many decades later.
Concerning Von Neumman's architecture:
Eckert was an electrical engineer, Mauchly a physicist.
Turing and von Neumman both made lasting contributions in the world of ideas, but they did not invent computers, not even close.