Is sincerity isomorphic to raising someone's status?
I'm not sure I know what you mean, or whether it relates to what I'm talking about. I'm just saying that if you're self-consciously trying to find things to praise that you don't genuinely value or don't genuinely believe people should be praised for, then you will certainly convey that you think you are of higher status or that your target is gullible, or other negative things (e.g., via perception of condescension).
It's entirely possible to connote pleasure with an achievement, team pride, or other sincere positive emotions that do not raise anybody's status; not everything in human interaction is status-based.
Does that answer your question?
My hypothesis is that when people give insincere praise, they are saying things that would ordinarily raise someone's status, but subtle cues related to tone or body language betray the fact that they are not in fact assigned the person a higher status.
To disprove the hypothesis, we could try to think of a scenario where someone gives insincere praise while simultaneously assigning the person higher status with that praise. I can't think of any such scenario but maybe you can.
Note that achievement and team pride both basically amount to status.
From the Harvard Business Review, an article entitled: "Can We Reverse The Stanford Prison Experiment?"
By: Greg McKeown
Posted: June 12, 2012
Clicky Link of Awesome! Wheee! Push me!
Summary:
Royal Canadian Mounted Police attempt a program where they hand out "Positive Tickets"
This idea can be applied to Real Life