Viliam_Bur comments on Should you try to do good work on LW? - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (32)
This is too abstract for me. What exactly means "good work"? Let's say that I wrote some article, or just plan to write an article, and I ask myself -- is LW the right place to publish it?
Well, it depends on the topic, on the style of writing, and what kind of audience / reaction do I want. There are more things to consider than just "good" or "bad". Is it a Nobel price winning material? Then I send it to a prestigious scientific journal. Is it just a new idea I want feedback on? Then I guess whether I get better feedback on LW or somewhere else; again, the choices depend on topic. Something personal? I put it on my blog. Etc. Use your judgement.
It is also possible to write to a scientific journal and post a hyperlink on LW, or to write a concept on LW, collect feedback, improve the article and send it somewhere else.
Yes, if the work is optimized for LW, it is not optimized for <something else>. Different audiences require different styles. Maybe LW could have a subsection where the articles must be written using the scientific lingo (preferably in a two-column, single-spaced format), or maybe we are OK with drafts. I prefer legibility, journals prefer brevity, other people may prefer something else.