Eliezer_Yudkowsky comments on Welcome to Less Wrong! (July 2012) - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (843)
Do we know about any such proteins related to LTM? Can we make predictions about what it takes to erase C. elegans maze memory this way?
Would strongly predict that such changes erase only information about short term activity, not long term memory. Protein conformation in response to electrochemical/osmotic gradients operates on the timescale of individual firings, it's probably too flimsy to encode stable memories. These should be easy for Skynet to recover.
Higher level pattens of firings might conceivably store information, but experience with anaesthesia, hypothermia etc. says they do not. Or we've been killing people and replacing them all this time... a possibility which thanks to this site I'm prepared to consider..
Oh, and
Bam.
http://www.nature.com/news/diamond-defects-shrink-mri-to-the-nanoscale-1.12343
Here we have moved far past my ability to even speculate.
Presumably you can use google and wikipedia to fill in the gaps just like the rest of us.
Wikipedia: Long-term memory
What I worry about being confused on when reading the literature is the distinction between forming memories in the first place, and actually encoding for memory.
Another critical distinction is that, proteins that are needed to prevent degradation of memories over time (which get lots of research and emphasis in the literature due to their role in preventing degenerative diseases) aren't necessarily the ones directly encoding for the memories.
So in subjects I know a lot about, I have dealt with many people who pick up strange notions by filling in the gaps from google and wikipedia with a weak foundation. The work required to effectively figure out what specific damage to the specific proteins you mentioned could be done by desiccation of a cell is beyond my knowledge base, so I leave it to someone more knowledgeable than myself(perhaps you?) to step in.
What open/closed states does PKMζ have? What regulates those open/closed states? Are the open/closed states important to its roll (it looks like yes given the notion of the inhibitor?)?
Yes, it's important to build a strong foundation before establishing firm opinions. Also, in this particular case note that science appears to have recently changed it's mind based on further evidence, which goes to show that you have to be careful when reading wikipedia. Apparently the protein in question is not so likely to underlie LTM after all, as transgenic mice lacking it still have LTM (exhibiting maze memory, LTP, etc). The erasure of memory is linked to zeta inhibitory peptide (ZIP), which incidentally happens in the transgenic mice as well.
ETA: Apparently PKMzeta can be used to restore faded memories erased with ZIP.