Stephen_Barnes comments on Open Thread, August 16-31, 2012 - Less Wrong

3 Post author: OpenThreadGuy 15 August 2012 03:25AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (313)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: [deleted] 16 August 2012 12:03:29AM 3 points [-]

Is there any sort of prevailing opinion in LW about diet? For instance, paleo, IF, CR, etc. The only posts I could find are inconclusive and from years back.

Comment author: jsteinhardt 25 August 2012 09:12:21AM 3 points [-]

Paleo seems to be popular around here but I am pretty skeptical of it actually being a good idea (I am open to updating if evidence is presented). Intermittent fasting is the only thing I really feel like I can recommend, and even that is something that will work for some people but not others (did not work for me, but LeanGains makes specific enough predictions that a sufficiently large number of people seem satisfied by that I am convinced it is a real phenomenon).

Also fixing any deficiencies you have (more water if you are dehydrated, for instance; probably more protein if you are a vegetarian).

Comment author: Sly 16 August 2012 07:06:15PM 7 points [-]

A very simple and easy first step is cutting out all liquids except for water (if that is too difficult, start with the soda). This helps a lot.

Comment author: OrphanWilde 16 August 2012 01:21:56AM 3 points [-]

If you're looking for a good diet, the first question is - a good diet for what?

Comment author: Dallas 16 August 2012 04:00:56AM 2 points [-]

I think there is a vague consensus that, all other things equal, eating less will make you lose weight and eating more will make you gain weight? I might have seen someone post a counterexample at least once, but I might simply be misremembering.

Comment author: Manfred 20 August 2012 04:08:29PM *  1 point [-]

The consensus I've picked up is that if you focus on just eating the right macronutrients and getting some exercise, everything else usually works out - try to replace sugar, refined starch, and processed fruit/vegetable product with protein, lowish glycemic index starch, and less bland fruit/veg.

Another idea that was useful to me is that mass-produced food has to have a low water content, or else it goes bad really quickly, and so replacing water with fat is a great way to make mass-produced food better. But in fresh food there's no such limitation. This means that eating fresher food basically substitutes fat for water in a lot of your food items.

Comment author: siodine 17 August 2012 05:36:56PM *  0 points [-]
  1. Make it difficult to consume more calories than the amount of calories necessary for maintaining your target weight. E.g., make it such that you need to eat a lot of food everyday to reach the maintenance level for your target weight (fast food, e.g., makes it very very easy to go over that target). Or you only eat after a certain time late in the day.

  2. Religiously monitor your progress. Take pictures of your back, side, front every week. Weigh yourself everyday. Take measurements -- use us navy body fat calculator. Find a way to show off your progress. (This is all purely motivational.)

  3. Do the kind of exercise that you will excel at with your desired body type. If you want to be muscular, do a lot of body weight exercises. If you want to be lean, do a lot of long distance running. But note that some body types require different nutritional compositions.

  4. This must be a lifestyle change, and not a temporary thing to just lose fat.

  5. You need to believe it will work, and continually adapt to setbacks.

eta: this is what I've gathered from the research showing the strategies of people successful at losing body fat and maintaining a lower bf%.