afsd;ljkurjzvn,x
The above comment would be insightful if it was a counterexample. This means it is not a counterexample. That means that it is not insightful. That means it is a counterexample. It's like the least interesting number paradox of nonsense strings of letters.
Regardless, I might recognize the technical accuracy of your point, but your point is only superficially useful. I liked the original comment and thought that it was both funny and insightful. Yes, some of that insight is mine as well, rocks can't sing or dance or use logic, but that doesn't mean that the initial comment isn't also interesting.
Master version on gwern.net