MixedNuts comments on The Rosenhan Experiment - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (20)
Staff behavior is easiest to judge (patients can't see hospital notes, and if you're not faking you can't judge the diagnosis much). Here's my experience in the acute psychiatric wing of a Swedish public hospital:
I am not psychotic (as far as I know, ha) but had a symptom a few years back that I mentioned when asked. (I think they screen everyone for psychosis.) They focused on that a lot, but did not medicate me for it.
I was voluntarily hospitalized. I don't know if demanding to leave would have worked. I was able to get day permissions and then released basically by being visibly happy then telling doctors so.
Nobody asked me to self-diagnose!
That one's true - medication (not antipsychotics in my case) was not optional.
Taking meds is the only time we were actively watched (except for patients on suicide watch).
Nuh-uh.
30 minutes every weekday morning with two doctors and a nurse, in a private room. I think this is standard procedure in Sweden.