As a scientist, I don’t come to work on Monday and make an observation, then form a hypothesis on Tuesday, devise an experiment to test some prediction on Wednesday, perform the experiment Thursday, and interpret the result on Friday. On any given day I would be hard pressed to tell you where I am in the process. All of the above, really. It’s a mess.
That is a large part of the reason why we have problems like the file drawer effect and data dredging.
I don't think that thinking categorically and mechanically would be feasibly productive.
It's a reality that we have to think messily in order to solve problems quickly, even if that efficiency also causes biases.
Here's the new thread for posting quotes, with the usual rules: