fubarobfusco comments on Using existing Strong AIs as case studies - Less Wrong

-6 Post author: ialdabaoth 16 October 2012 10:59PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (14)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: fubarobfusco 17 October 2012 01:35:39AM -1 points [-]

"You can't prove it's not!" arguments...?

Recommended reading: the Mysterious Answers to Mysterious Questions sequence.

Comment author: ialdabaoth 17 October 2012 01:42:08AM *  2 points [-]

No, I was presenting a potential counter to the idea that "I'm not sure whether 'team spirit' might be a projection in the minds of members or observers".

It might or might not be a projection in the minds of observers, but I don't think that it's relevant whether it is or not to the questions I'm asking, in the same sense that "are we conscious because we have a homunculus-soul inside of us, or because neurons give rise to consciousness?" isn't relevant to the question of "are we conscious?"

We know we are conscious as a bald fact, and we accept that other humans are conscious whenever we reject solipsism; we happen to be finding out the manner in which we are conscious as a result of our scientific curiosity.

But accepting an entity as "conscious" / "self-aware" / "sapient" does not require that we understand the mechanisms that generate its behavior; only that we recognize that it has behavior that fits certain criteria.