You have physical dysphoria independently from perception of gender by others. How does that not clinch it utterly and completely?
Because while it exists for both primary and secondary sexually dimorphic characteristics, it is much stronger for the secondary ones.
Also, can such feelings not be generated by motivated cognition? See body dysmorphic disorder.
Because while it exists for both primary and secondary sexually dimorphic characteristics, it is much stronger for the secondary ones.
That is actually not uncommon -- I can only offer anecdata here as I'm not aware of any studies on the matter, but have met rather a lot of trans and genderqueer people who find secondary dimorphic characteristics to be much more emotionally-salient to dysphoria than the state of their genitalia. It also not infrequently shifts over time -- some people seem to change on that after being hormones for a while, or after gett...
If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post, even in Discussion, it goes here.