More_Right comments on The Evil AI Overlord List - Less Wrong

27 Post author: Stuart_Armstrong 20 November 2012 05:02PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (80)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: More_Right 24 April 2014 08:04:02PM 0 points [-]

I don't know, in terms of dystopia, I think that an AGI might decide to "phase us out" prior to the singularity, if it was really malevolent. Make a bunch of attractive but sterile women robots, and a bunch of attractive but sterile male robots. Keep people busy with sex until they die of old age. A "gentle good night" abolition of humanity that isn't much worse (or way better) than what they had experienced for 50M years.

Releasing sterile attractive mates into a population is a good "low ecological impact" way of decreasing a population. Although, why would a superintelligence be opposed to _all humans? I find this somewhat unlikely, given a self-improving design.

Comment author: Stuart_Armstrong 25 April 2014 09:47:40AM 1 point [-]

This is probably not the most efficient use of the AGI's time and resources...

Comment author: More_Right 26 April 2014 09:08:42AM -1 points [-]

Probably true, but I agree with Peter Voss. I don't think any malevolence is the most efficient use of the AGI's time and resources. I think AGI has nothing to gain from malevolence. I don't think the dystopia I posited is the most likely outcome of superintelligence. However, while we are on the subject of the forms a malevolent AGI might take, I do think this is the type of malevolence most likely to be allow the malevolent AGI to retain a positive self-image.

(Much the way environmentalists can feel better about introducing sterile males into crop-pest populations, and feel better about "solving the problem" without polluting the environment.)

Ted Kaczynski worried about this scenario a lot. ...I'm not much like him in my views.

Comment author: Stuart_Armstrong 26 April 2014 09:41:56PM 0 points [-]

The most efficient use of time and resources will be to best accomplish the AI's goals. If these goals are malovent or lethally I different, so will the AI's actions. Unless these goals include maintaining a particular self image, the AI will have no seed to maintain any erroneous self image.