Spurlock comments on LW Women: LW Online - Less Wrong

29 [deleted] 15 February 2013 01:43AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (590)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: Spurlock 18 February 2013 05:22:57PM *  1 point [-]

The important question is whether this interpretation is true.

Fair point. I think I was using this as a proxy for truth, the same way you might ask "do economists believe X?" instead of "is X true about the economy?". But also I was up late.

Why? All you've shown is that this correlation doesn't fully screen off gender.

True. It is possible that empathic ability is affected by both gender and analytical disposition directly, rather than gender by-way-of analytical disposition. Or more realistically, that empathic ability is affected by analytical-ness as well as other, orthogonal personality traits, and that these might be gender-correlated as well. This interpretation seems messy from a complexity standpoint, but such is the subject matter.

I wonder what other personality traits we'd have to account for before we could explain the gender difference. Also, there's the question of just how much of the difference is left over once we've screened off however much analytical disposition screens off. Again, I'm just hashing out confusion here, not claiming to have solutions.

Comment author: Eugine_Nier 19 February 2013 01:39:20AM -1 points [-]

Fair point. I think I was using this as a proxy for truth, the same way you might ask "do economists believe X?" instead of "is X true about the economy?".

You really need to get better proxies for truth.

Comment author: Spurlock 19 February 2013 04:57:51AM 2 points [-]

Well, if nothing else comes out of this exchange, at least I can now relate to the OP that much better.

Comment author: bogdanb 09 March 2013 04:38:56PM 0 points [-]

Weird. I read Eugine's "better proxies" comment as an obvious joke, and had to think for at least five seconds to realize what your reply meant. I can't tell for sure if I would have taken it as criticism if it were directed at me, but I can see how it could be unpleasant if I had.

Priors to update: I can't tell if a comment is unpleasantly critical as well as I thought I did.