Yes, I'd like to avoid that sort of ..um.. proposal -- I can't quite see why one would call it a syllogism.

People would act as if it is a syllogism if they had one of the relevant (and not especially uncommon/unrealistic) premises. It would be a syllogism like...

• Susie said a bad thing
• People who say bad things should be set on fire
• Therefore, Susie should be set on fire.