jbash comments on Ritual 2012: A Moment of Darkness - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (136)
Does anybody in your group have children? It doesn't seem to me that what you have in your ritual book would serve them very well. Even ignoring any possible desire to "recruit" the children themselves, that means that adults who have kids will have an incentive to leave the community.
Maybe it's just that I personally was raised with zero attendance at anything remotely that structured, but it's hard for me to imagine kids sitting through all those highly abstract stories, many of which rely on lots of background concepts, and being anything but bored stiff (and probably annoyed). Am I wrong?
Even if they could sit through it happily, there's the question of whether having them chant things they don't understand respects their agency or promotes their own growth toward reasoned examination of the world and their beliefs about it. Especially when, as somebody else has mentioned, the ritual includes stuff that's not just "rationalism". Could there be more to help them understand how to get to the concepts, so that they could have a reasonable claim not to just be repeating "scripture"?
Or am I just worrying about something unreal?
(shrugs) You're not wrong, but I'm not sure you're right either.
In my own case, growing up as an Orthodox Jew involved sitting through lots of highly abstract ritual observances that relied on lots of background concepts (and frequently being bored stiff and annoyed). And if a rationalist group is only as successful at retaining the involvement of parents and their kids as Orthodox Judaism is, dayenu. (Which is to say: that would be sufficient.)
More generally, I suspect that it's perfectly possible to involve kids in something that structured, it just requires giving the kids roles they can engage with in that structure.
A comment I made in the introduction article:
More generally, each community that wants this will need to customize it for their own needs. Daenerys' event in Ohio didn't end up having singing or litanies at all, instead being built around custom vows and affirmations.