hirvinen comments on Catchy Fallacy Name Fallacy (and Supporting Disagreement) - Less Wrong

23 Post author: JGWeissman 21 May 2009 06:01AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (56)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: conchis 21 May 2009 09:19:03AM 9 points [-]

I agree that this is a danger, and that it's something we should be wary of, in both ourselves and others.

But I'm not sure we should require people to spell things out in excruciating detail every time they think someone else has committed an error. It's probably a good mental discipline to go through this process in your own head, to check that you're not firing off an unwarranted accusation, but sometimes it really is pretty obvious that a particular error has been committed, and in such cases the shorthand seems both useful and justified. If it's still unclear to others, I'm fairly sure someone will come forward and say so (and they should be encouraged to do so).

Maybe I'm wrong about this. I'd be interested in others' opinions.

Comment author: hirvinen 28 May 2009 03:48:17PM 0 points [-]

sometimes it really is pretty obvious that a particular error has been committed

The degree or lack of obviousness is a fact about the reader's mind, not about the error.

Comment author: conchis 28 May 2009 06:02:02PM 0 points [-]

Of course. By "pretty obvious" I meant "obvious to most readers" (obviously! :P).