You cannot cross a chasm by pointing to the far side and saying, "Suppose there was a bridge to there? Then we could cross!"
I'm, ah, not sure what this refers to. Going with my best guess, here:
If you have some problem with my formulation of, and responce to, the quote retooled for "rationality", please provide your own.
He isn't addressing Christians. He's addressing people who are atheists already, getting in a good dig at those dumb Christians who think that a monkey gave birth to a human, sorry, that anyone should kill their child if God tells them to. Ha ha ha! Is he not witty!
He is not "getting in a good dig at those dumb Christians who think that a monkey gave birth to a human, sorry, that anyone should kill their child if God tells them to." He is attemppting to demonstrate to Christians that they do not alieve that they should do anything God says. I think he is mistaken in this, but it's not inconsistant or trivially wrong, as some commenters here seem to think.
(He also appears to think that this is the wrong position to hold, which is puzzling; I'd like to see his reasoning on that.)
He is attemppting to demonstrate to Christians that they do not alieve that they should do anything God says. I think he is mistaken in this, but it's not inconsistant or trivially wrong, as some commenters here seem to think.
It seems trivially wrong to me, but maybe that's just from having some small familiarity with how intellectually serious Christians actually do things (and the non-intellectual hicks are unlikely to be knocked down by Penn's rhetoric either). It is absolutely standard in Christianity that any apparent divine revelation must be exam...
Happy New Year! Here's the latest and greatest installment of rationality quotes. Remember: