This is fine, but unfair, especially so for discussion. It takes years to familiarize oneself with the field. I'm not saying I agree with these arguments or that they haven't been dealt with, but I haven't seen their treatment in over two years on LessWrong, and the arguments don't seem obviously wrong (to me). ...And Brian Tomasik is moderately familiar with the field (though no expert).

Could you at least link to some resources you think answer these objections?