prase comments on Newcomb's Problem dissolved? - Less Wrong

-4 Post author: EGI 25 February 2013 03:34PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (17)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: prase 28 February 2013 05:31:53PM 0 points [-]

As I understand the responses most people think the main point of Newcomb's problem is that you rationally should cooperate given the 1000000 / 1000 payoff matrix.

I am no expert on Newomb's problem history, but I think it was specifically constructed as a counter-example to the common-sensical decision-theoretic principle that one should treat past events as independent of the decisions being made now. That's as well how it is most commonly interpreted on LW, although the concept of a near-omniscient predictor "Omega" is employed in wide range of different thought experiments here and it's possible that your objection can be relevant to some of them.

I am not sure whether it makes sense to call one-boxing cooperation. Newcomb isn't Prisoner's dilemma, at least in the original form.