The animal training book Don't Shoot the Dog states that reinforcement-oriented clicker training is substantially faster and more persistent than aversion-based alternatives.
Oh, of course. Positive reinforcement in general is stronger, which I would have noticed if I hadn't been primed by reading about anxiety recently, which suggests I should institute some sort of debiasing exercise when I recognize the risk of selection bias rather than just announcing it.
There are two confusing but potentially important papers in the Jan. 25 2013 Science on long-term memory (LTM) formation in fruit flies:
Pierre-Yves Placais & Thomas Preat. To favor survival under food shortage, the brain disables costly memory. 339:440-441.
Yukinori Hirano et al. Fasting launches CRTC to facilitate long-term memory formation in Drosophila. 339:443-446.
These papers categorize long-term memory formation along three axes.
The relationship between these is unclear, particularly as each of these three axes is claimed at various times to determine whether memory can be learned in a single training cycle (appetitive, fLTM, and/or ARM) or not (aversive, spLTM, and/or LTM). But these things appear to be likely, or at least to be reasonable hypotheses, if these pathways are conserved in humans:
I'd really appreciate it if somebody would do a literature review and a comparison of the pathways involved to those in humans, and summarize their findings.