ArisKatsaris comments on Tactics against Pascal's Mugging - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (59)
If we're to talk directly about what Dmytry is talking about without beating around the bush, an asteroid killed the dinosaurs and AI did not, therefore discussion of asteroids is not Pascal's mugging and discussion of AI risks is; the former makes you merely scientifically aware, and the latter makes you a fraudster, a crackpot or a sucker. If AI risks were real, then surely the dinosaurs would have been killed by an AI instead.
So, let's all give money to prevent an asteroid extinction event that we know only happens once in a few hundred million years, and let's not pay any attention to AI risks, because AI risks afterall never happened to the dinosaurs, and must therefore be impossible, much like self-driving cars, heavier-than-air flight, or nuclear bombs.
... doesn't GiveWell recommend that for pretty much every charity, because you should be giving it to the Top Three Effective Charities?
Which mission? The FAI mission? The GiveWell mission? I am confused :(
I don't suppose he said this somewhere linkable?
Here he claims that the default outcome of AI is very likely safe, but attempts at Friendly AI are very likely deadly if they do anything (although I would argue this neglects the correlation between what AI approaches are workable in general and for would-be FAI efforts, and what is dangerous for both types, as well as assuming some silly behaviors and that competitive pressures aren't severe):
Downvoted for ranting.
I thought it was satire?
It is. It's also a rant.
It makes a good point, mind, and I upvoted it, but it's still needlessly ranty.
Then maybe my sarcasm/irony/satire detector is broken.
Well, I seriously doubt Aris actually thinks AI risks are Pascal's Mugging by definition. That doesn't prevent this from being a rant, it's just a sarcastic rant.