MugaSofer comments on Post ridiculous munchkin ideas! - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (1240)
Could you expand on this, please? I'm not sure I'm familiar with the failure mode you seem to be pattern-matching to.
The point is that when someone "hears voices" - which do not respond to the will in the same way in which internal monologues do, there's no demons, there's no new brain added. It is existing brain regions involved in the internal monologue failing to integrate properly with the rest. Less dramatically, when people claim they e.g. want to get on a diet but are mysteriously unable to - their actions do not respond to what they think is their will but instead respond to what they think is not their will - it's the regions which make decisions about food intake not integrating with the regions that do the talking (Proper integration either results in the diet or absence of the belief that one wants to be on a diet). The bottom line is, brain is not a single CPU of some kind. It is a distributed system parts of which are capable of being in conflict, to the detriment of the well being of the whole.
So ... you're worried this might increase akrasia? I guess I can see how they might be in the same category, but I don't think the same downsides apply. Do they?