If I am precisely cloned, I should anticipate either clone's experience with 50% probability
Shouldn't you anticipate being either clone with 100% probability, since both clones will make that claim and neither can be considered wrong?
What I meant is that some time after the cloning, the clones' lives would become distinguishable. One of them would experience X, while the other would experience ~X. Then I would anticipate experiencing X with 50% probability.
If they live identical lives forever, then I can anticipate "being either clone" or as I would call it, "not being able to tell which clone I am".
Another month has passed and here is a new rationality quotes thread. The usual rules are: