LP comments on Universal Fire - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (42)
"If you stepped into a world where matches failed to strike, you would cease to exist as organized matter."
Okay, I can see your point here -- if I ask you to imagine being transported to another planet where things are kind of the same, except the matches don't work, you'd be justified in being skeptical. I always worried about this when I watched Star Trek -- how come the crew never accidentally vaporized after beaming down to a planet with just slightly different local laws of physics?
But mythology is different from science fiction -- mythology is populated by gods, where gods are defined not just as 'so much more powerful than we humans that we perceive them as god-like,' but as actual, omnipotent gods, capable of manipulating or simply disregarding 'laws' of the physical universe. If you visit this world, you'd best check any thoughts of a 'tighly-laced reality' at the door.
The laws of physics are constant between planets. Everywhere in the universe, in fact.
Maybe not: Variations in fine-structure constant suggest laws of physics not the same everywhere
Still, in that case, I'd call the real laws of physics the meta-laws by which the object level laws vary.
I think that when LP said, "world," he meant the fictional universe of Norse mythology, not a different planet.
I think they were reacting to this line, not the one about other worlds.