JoshuaZ comments on A Ketogenic Diet as an Effective Cancer Treatment? - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (21)
Many of those references don't support the claim or only support it very weakly. For example, one of the articles in the long list of citations is this one, and says:
So the data isn't quite that strong. Some of the other bits above are a little weaker than one would hope for:
But the reference for 25 is only for brain tumors in certain limited contexts in children.
Overall, this is an interesting area of ongoing work, but it isn't nearly as universal as you might think. There are also other issues involved: people with late stage cancers often have enough trouble eating as is (a large fraction actually die of starvation), and getting them to eat anything is an accomplishment. So at that level, for a lot of post-metastasis patients, this will be happening naturally anyways.
Starvation does not equal ketosis. If cancer patients are suffering from nausea and lack of motivation to eat anything, they and their carers may not select high fat low carbohydrate foods that would promote and sustain ketosis and may instead choose simple and easy to digest carbohydrates and sugary treats.
(Your comment upvoted.)