gwern comments on Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality discussion thread, part 19, chapter 88-89 - Less Wrong

12 Post author: Vaniver 30 June 2013 01:22AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (957)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: glomerulus 01 July 2013 02:28:30AM 2 points [-]

This only qualifies as a sane response if one has no ethical qualms about the Imperius curse. Which is a bit of a problem, because most sane people wouldn't like the idea.

Putting aside the sketchiness of the idea itself, it's flawed. If any zombie high on the chain dies or makes their will-save, every zombie subservient to them is freed, and has knowledge of the Grand Imperius Effort. If, before the experience, they hadn't had strong feelings either way about nonconsensual use of mind-effecting spells, they certainly will afterwards; everyone post-zombie is likely to oppose the plan.

I suppose you could ameliorate the first bit of the first part of the practical problem by sequestering high-level zombies so they don't die, and the rest with sufficient use of propaganda. This assumes that this program is endorsed by a quite powerful organization.

If we assume control of a powerful organization, though, it'd be more effective, and slightly less hideously unethical, just to sterilize all magicians and eliminate the "devastating, distributed destructive powers of magic" in a generation or two. Or write an Interdict of MerLarks to encompass all non-healing spells.

Comment author: gwern 01 July 2013 03:10:13AM 13 points [-]

After devising a plan for a GNU world order, it's only logical to take the next step up into resilient W2W (Wizard-to-Wizard) networks: add a clause ordering Imperiused wizards to re-infect every 100th wizard they meet. This random crosslinking will convert the efficient yet fragile pyramidal hierarchy into a robust distributed graph.

Comment author: ikrase 01 July 2013 08:25:34AM 1 point [-]

Does Imperius provide remote control, or simply obedience to mundane orders? What does self-inflicted Imperius do?

Comment author: Axel 01 July 2013 12:42:09PM 8 points [-]

What does self-inflicted Imperius do

The cure to procrastination?

Comment author: ikrase 01 July 2013 01:28:21PM 0 points [-]

It seems to me like having somebody imperius yourself to do what you wanted to do in the first place might be a way to make yourself formiddable in general. Of course, it also might break your free will or cause quietism or solipsism?

Comment author: NancyLebovitz 01 July 2013 02:02:21PM 2 points [-]

It would also be an education in finding out to what extent what you want to do in far mode is actually a way of getting what you want.

Comment author: MugaSofer 29 July 2013 07:19:11PM -1 points [-]

Bit of both, really. It's described as "like moving your arm", yet the subject retains their own skillset, mannerisms etc.