SaidAchmiz comments on Welcome to Less Wrong! (6th thread, July 2013) - Less Wrong

21 Post author: KnaveOfAllTrades 26 July 2013 02:35AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (513)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: SaidAchmiz 05 August 2013 02:33:05AM 1 point [-]

I completely agree that Searle believes in magic (aka "intentionality"), which is not useful. But this does not mean the Chinese Room problem isn't real.

I agree that Searle believes in magic, but "intentionality" is not magic (see: almost anything Dennett has written).

When you study human language use empirically in natural contexts (through frame-by-frame analysis of video recordings), it turns out that what we think we do with language and what we actually do are rather divergent. The body and places in the world and other agents in the interaction all play a much bigger role in the real-time construction of meaning than you would expect from introspection.

This sounds interesting. Could you expand on this?

Comment author: telms 05 August 2013 04:47:08AM 1 point [-]

A list of references can be found in an earlier post in this thread.