Romashka comments on Fake Causality - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (86)
"Since the Theory of Evolution is in the business of explaining the past and present rather than predicting the future"
Ouch! I hope not! That makes it sound awful! Theories should be consistent with existing observations - sure - but a bigger challenge for them comes in predicting new observations before they are made.
There is at least one rather specialised area in which theory offers predictions - evolution of communities. It's like, 'when true grasses appeared, they made, through having some novel features, created grasslands. They circumvented successions that would lead to preexistent plant habitats; in the beginning, they were weeds compared to the rest of vegetation. Nowadays, we have a group of species that spread widely, are considered weeds and share ecological similarity, not [relatively recent] common ancestor. We predict that in future, these weeds will form habitats through disruption of current eco networks.' Admittedly, this is hard to observe.