Pentashagon comments on I notice that I am confused about Identity and Resurrection - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (80)
Poor Shen Chun-lieh should have just said he wanted the {CEV} of Ah-Chen + Shen-Chun-lieh.
I don't think anything less than CEV or equivalent will actually pinpoint individual identity sufficiently well that we will have no complaints about resurrecting people from the best information available. If I had to manually pinpoint my own identity I would accidentally carve off entire swaths that I don't even know I have and distort the other parts. The physical description of my body at the planck scale is too limited; I would never change. Au-Chen brought back from the dead perfectly would be a little girl dying of smallpox; curing the smallpox would destroy her planck-scale identity. I don't know what level of accuracy is sufficient. I can only assume that it's somewhere between planck scale (or even atomic scale) accuracy and the mess that is ~80 years of gene-driven growth and change of a human body.
You have captured the essence of the problem, here.