knb comments on Links: so-called "knockout game" a "myth and a "bogus trend." - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (24)
I don't know if the knockout game is really on the rise or whether the issue is even important, but I would caution against the general pattern of seeing a blog post which seems to confirm your assumptions and then crowing triumphantly without really engaging the issue.
The blog post you're relying on to describe this as a bogus trend is extremely weak. It offers no new research or evidence and uses faulty logic in at least some parts. I won't write a full takedown but this part seems like a pretty glaring logical error. The blogger points out that an anonymous "Dutchtown woman" says her white son participated in a knockout game and that it isn't a "black thing." The blogger then asks:
Probably because Torres didn't just rely on the opinion of "one Dutchtown woman," looked at the other available articles where racial descriptions were available, and made conclusions based on that.