Hm... As an alternative category, how about "worth the effort of spending a few hours reading up on the details and implications" as opposed to "sufficiently unlikely that my time would be better spent looking for new rationalist (fan)fiction"?
Worth the effort to what end? For example, educational value of settled science is greater than that of almost any topic for which the question of being pseudoscience or "protoscience" even comes up (judged at the level where you are ready to study the topic).
There are a great many ideas which don't have enough carefully-measured evidence to be sufficiently confirmed as scientific fact and accepted as such by the scientific community (a recent joke was "While the Higgs Boson has not been discovered yet, its mass is 125 GeV"), but don't have enough carefully-measured evidence to be ruled out yet, either. Do any of the tools of the LW community help narrow down which ones are more worthy of consideration than others?
Eg:
* Cryonics as an arguably reasonable bet for its cost: proto-science
* Cryonics as a surefire way to achieve immortality: nigh-certainly pseudoscience (unless it's the method by which your Everett Immortality keeps you alive)
* Using math to demonstrate that taking classical physics and adding determinism results in MWI-style quantum physics: proto-science.
* Using math to demonstrate that quantum physics proves Christianity is true, from a certain point of view: pseudo-science
* Tubulin might self-organize into microtubules capable of computation on a sub-neuron scale: Possibly proto-science
* Tubulin architecture is 'quantum' in nature and that is what gives rise to consciousness: Probably pseudo-science
* 'Quantum consciousness' means anything is possible: Downright silly
* The E8 Lie group can provide a system for organizing the properties of subatomic particles: Proto-science, perhaps
* Heim theory is useful for predicting particle masses: Pseudo-science, probabilistically
* Using the Bullet Cluster to claim that dark matter is a better theory than Modified Newtonian Dynamics: proto-science
* Claiming that dark matter is made of 'anapoles': Proto-science, perchance
* Suggesting that dark matter is actually gravitational leakage from MWI 'parallel universes': You tell me. (But if it's true, then since I can't seem to find any previous serious discussion of this idea, I get to name part of it after myself, right? :) )
These may not be the best examples, but they're the closest ones I can think of to the boundary. If you know of any better ones, feel free to comment with them.