At the very low end, a certain amount of karma must be earned for certain functionality to become available to a user account. But past a certain point -- somewhere in the 200-500 range -- more karma just doesn't matter very much when assessing a user account. After that point, the meaning of a karma score attaches much more strongly to specific comments than to users.
The corollary is that the karma reward will incent newcomers a lot more than old hands. I don't have a problem with that.
My point was really that karma isn't tied to who is right, it is tied to who we like or who furthers our preferential ends.
The "who we like" part seems to be how some people operate, especially vis-a-vis mass downvoting. I view that as counterproductive. What the phrase "furthers our preferential ends" denotes is not clear to me; if it means something like an upvote is meant to signal "I want to see more like this comment" and a downvote the opposite, then my understanding of LW consensus is, yes, that's the idea.
But past a certain point -- somewhere in the 200-500 range -- more karma just doesn't matter very much when assessing a user account.
Huh? If karma isn't very meaningful past a certain count, why keep track of it at all? Why not just call everybody who reached 500 karma points "vetted" and leave it at that? (I suspect the answer is that karma does matter to some significant portion of the people here, but I'm open to hearing why you think otherwise.)
...The "who we like" part seems to be how some people operate, especially vis-a-vis ma
MIRI is gathering a bunch of Eliezer’s writings into a nicely-edited ebook, currently titled The Hard Part is Actually Changing Your Mind. This book will ultimately be released in various digital formats (Kindle MOBI, EPUB, and PDF). Much of the initial work for this project is complete. What we need now are volunteers to review the book's chapters to:
This project has been added to Youtopia, MIRI’s volunteer system. (Click “Register as a Volunteer” here to sign up. Already signed up? Go here.)
LW Karma Bonus
For this special project, every point earned in Youtopia will also earn you 3 karma on LW!
Points are awarded based on the amount of time spent proofreading the book. For example, an hour of work logged in Youtopia earns you 10 points, which will also get you 30 LW karma. Karma is awarded by admins in a publicly-accountable way: all manual karma additions are listed here.
Questions about this project can be directed to alexv@intelligence.org or in the comments.