army1987 comments on Doubt, Science, and Magical Creatures - a Child's Perspective - Less Wrong

33 Post author: Benquo 28 December 2013 03:26PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (53)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: [deleted] 30 December 2013 11:41:24AM *  1 point [-]

if she took the dime even once, people would stop inviting her to play that game.

And that would be a bad thing why? Did she enjoy being chuckled at?

Comment author: Wes_W 30 December 2013 05:16:51PM 9 points [-]

Probably not, but she did enjoy extra spending money. Remember that this story (ostensibly, although see NancyLebovitz's comment) takes place long enough ago that a nickel could actually buy something.

If I were to assign a moral to the story, it would be something like "don't assume children aren't extremely clever". The girl not only understood the game on the object level, but also grasped the metagame and turned it to her advantage.

(The meta-moral for myself would be "remember that some of your relatives are senile enough to misremember jokes as autobiographical".)

Comment author: ygert 30 December 2013 11:52:13AM *  8 points [-]

I think the point is that she enjoyed getting free money more than she disliked being chuckled at, so she was willing to suffer being chuckled at in order to receive the free money.

Comment author: William_Quixote 30 December 2013 11:59:09AM 5 points [-]

People often do like making their relatives happy. If her family was laughing and having a good time it doesn't seem that strange for her to just play along.

I also wouldn't be shocked either if her family knew to some extent that she was playing along and that it was something of a family "in joke". (not the explicit kind of in joke, just an organic kind)