lmm comments on January 2014 Media Thread - Less Wrong

6 Post author: ArisKatsaris 01 January 2014 03:19PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (79)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: lmm 02 January 2014 07:27:57PM *  3 points [-]

The recommendation may have been from here originally but I can't find it now: To The Stars - incomplete, set in the far future of the Puella Magi Madoka☆Magica universe, contriving to shape the plot and tone into something resembling Starship Troopers (or more likely Old Man's War). I find the way it forces a fantasy story into quite hard sci-fi rather interesting; there are places where you can see the strain, but mostly it works well, and the characters strike a good balance, developed from but solidly rooted in their canon originals. I will say it's not that well written - the phrasing is distinctly clunky at times - but for me the plot, characters and especially the worldbuilding were good enough to shine through.

Comment author: Dorikka 03 January 2014 04:05:21AM 4 points [-]
Comment author: beoShaffer 03 January 2014 02:44:27AM 3 points [-]

The recommendation may have been from here originally but I can't find it now:

It's been recommended multiply times on LW and in the HPMoR author notes, but is worth re-recommending, particularly since you gave and above average summary. Also, the author lists Old Man's War as a significant inspiration, but has said elsewhere that he just took a few specific ideas and didn't actually like Old Man's War overall.

Comment author: ShardPhoenix 06 January 2014 07:17:59AM 2 points [-]

I've finally got around to reading this and I'm quite enjoying it so far, though it's a bit heavy on exposition and flashbacks.

Comment author: lmm 07 January 2014 09:27:03PM 0 points [-]

Ah yes, I'd forgotten how clunky those early exposition chapters are. Should've mentioned that.

Comment author: ShardPhoenix 08 January 2014 06:39:52AM *  0 points [-]

I think some parts would have been better if I was familiar with the Oriko Magica spinoff. At any rate I'm up to chapter 14 and it's moving much more smoothly. At this point I'm thinking that Ryouku is n pybar bs Znqbxn, juvyr ure tenaqcneragf ner cebonoyl Uvgbzv Fuvmhxv naq Xlōfhxr Xnzvwō (ylvat nobhg gurve ntrf).

edit: I appear to have mixed up maternal and paternal grandparents so I guess the second speculation above doesn't apply (at least not how I was thinking of it). Also chapter 14 clears things up a bit on this front anyway...