army1987 comments on Flashes of Nondecisionmaking - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (34)
"We may think we are doing -- indeed, we think we are doing at every moment -- but IT is doing. Our mechanical being is doing" -- Maurice Nicholl.
But “it” is you.
Nicoll is speaking in the context of the Gurdjieffian tradition, a.k.a. Fourth Way. "Mechanical being" is a technical term of that tradition and does not mean our physical embodiment. In his words:
These paragraphs include other technical terms, which are hyperlinked at the linked site.
Translated into the terminology of the tradition of LessWrong, he is talking about NPCs and PCs. The purpose of the Fourth Way teachings is to show people their nature as NPCs, the existence of the PC nature, and a way to achieve that state.
I make no claims for the efficacy of their methods, I just happen to have some acquaintance with the books.
How many billion neurons sure in your head? Are you sure they sum to one entity? Are you sure there is only one entity when you observe you?
This is a valuable response to the obvious interpretation, but perusing the source material (here) it looks like the quote was actually meant to describe psychological phenomena like habit formation, which is fairly reasonable. Probably. The source seems rather mysticised.