RichardKennaway comments on How to teach to magical thinkers? - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (79)
I can't resist...
Did scientific method grow on a tree, or did people invent it?
Did people invent scientific method simultaneously everywhere, or was it invented and practiced at specific places?
:D
The real fallacy in my opinion is having a connotation that if something is constructed and promoted within a culture, that makes it wrong. For example, consider the Pythagorean theorem... knowing that Pythagoras was a rich white cis male, shouldn't we remove it from the curriculum? And perhaps replace it with something more enlightened, such as: "all sides of a triangle are equal, even if their lengths may be different".
In the same sense, science, even rationality itself, are cultural constructs. Maybe even human speech is a cultural construct, but luckily that happened sufficiently long ago so now all cultures have it. Okay, I am not sure about the last example. But I am sure that calling things "cultural constructs" is a cultural construct itself.
It grew on a tree. Olives grow on trees too, but no-one knew you could eat them until someone discovered that soaking them in brine makes them edible.
Or less metaphorically, science was discovered, not invented. It works for reasons that have nothing to do with us.