eli_sennesh comments on "Smarter than us" is out! - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (56)
Only in the minds of "yay future!" sorts of people. My parents think self-publishing a non-fiction book is sketchy, and they have every valid reason for believing this. I agree with them, in fact.
Take the "outside view": if someone handed you a book and said, "This describes the most important scientific and moral challenge of our times", and you had never heard of MIRI/FHI/CFAR/LW in any way whatsoever, what are the questions you're going to ask? They'll almost definitely be credibility questions; you want to read a book that's been edited well and comes from some kind of well-known intellectual expert on the topic being discussed, preferably one from very credible institutions like academia and government. You're a non-expert, after all, and it's not worth your time becoming an expert on some obscure, highly technical topic just to judge whether you should spend $30 on a book.
Luckily, information above indicates that FHI is publishing Superintelligence under the Oxford University label, with actual academic credentials and such, in hardback print. I'll be waiting for that one before I recommend anything to "the normals".
"Why do you think so?"
Not in my case.
Oh, certainly not. Government is pretty much the opposite of a "credible institution" and as to academia, it depends on the field.
Do you think your views on this matter are typical of the audience to whom the book is targeted?