Houshalter comments on The Problem with AIXI - Less Wrong

24 Post author: RobbBB 18 March 2014 01:55AM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (78)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: RobbBB 13 March 2014 10:18:06AM *  1 point [-]

humans also don't grasp death on any deeper level than AIXI. They also drop anvils on their head so to speak

If human adults didn't grasp death any better than AIXI does, they'd routinely drop anvils on their heads literally, not 'so to speak'.

This is for the same reason AIXI does. Symbolic reasoning about reality.

What do you mean? What would be the alternative to 'symbolic reasoning'?

The body provides the 'reward' button. And that button can be hacked (drugs, optimizing for single values).

If a smart AI values things about the world outside its head, it won't deliberately hack itself (e.g., it won't alter its hardware to entertain happy delusions), because it won't expect a policy of self-hacking to make the world actually better. It's the actual world it cares about, not its beliefs about, preferences over, or enjoyable experiences of the world.

The problem with AIXI isn't that it lacks the data or technology needed to self-modify. It's that it has an unrealistic prior. These aren't problems shared by humans. Humans form approximately accurate models of how new drugs, food, injuries, etc. will affect their minds, and respond accordingly. They don't always do so, but AIXI is special because it can never do so, even when given unboundedly great computing power and arbitrarily large supplies of representative data.

Comment author: Houshalter 18 March 2014 09:12:35AM 4 points [-]

If human adults didn't grasp death any better than AIXI does, they'd routinely drop anvils on their heads literally, not 'so to speak'.

AIXI doesn't necessarily drop an anvil on it's head. It just doesn't believe that it's input sequence can ever stop, no matter what happens. This seems to me like what the vast majority of humans believe.

Comment author: jbay 18 March 2014 01:28:57PM 1 point [-]

For clarity: are you referring to belief in an afterlife/reincarnation? Or are you saying that most humans are not mindful most of the time of their own mortality?

Comment author: Houshalter 18 March 2014 02:46:44PM 0 points [-]

I am referring to an afterlife of some kind.