CellBioGuy comments on Irrationality Game III - Less Wrong

11 Post author: CellBioGuy 12 March 2014 01:51PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (204)

Sort By: Popular

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: CellBioGuy 12 March 2014 02:03:05PM *  5 points [-]

Irrationality game:

There are other 'technological civilizations' (in the sense of intelligent living things that have learned to manipulate matter in a complicated way) in the observable universe: 99%

There are other 'technological civilizations' in our own galaxy: 75% with most of the probability mass in regimes where there are somewhere between dozens and thousands.

Conditional on these existing: Despite some being very old, they are limited by the hostile nature of the universe and the realities of practical manipulation of matter and energy to never controlling much matter outside the surfaces of life-bearing worlds, and either never leave their solar systems of origin with anything self-replicating or their replicators on average produce less than 1 seed to continue. 95%

Humanity has already received and recorded a radio signal from another thing-analogous-to-a-technological-civilization. This was either unnoticed or not unequivocally recognized as such due to some combination of very short duration, being a one-off event that was never repeated, being modulated in a way that the receiver was not looking for, or being indistinguishable from terrestrial radio noise. 20%.

Conditional on the above, the "Wow!" signal was such a signal. 20%.

Comment author: [deleted] 16 March 2014 03:29:28AM 1 point [-]

There are other 'technological civilizations' (in the sense of intelligent living things that have learned to manipulate matter in a complicated way) in the observable universe: 99%

What do you mean by “complicated”? Were humans a technological civilization in 1900? In 1700? In 10,000 BC? In 50,000 BC?

Comment author: Eugine_Nier 13 March 2014 12:27:56AM 4 points [-]

One statement per comment please.

Comment author: CellBioGuy 13 March 2014 01:29:14AM 1 point [-]

Probably overdid it with that one. Will split things up more in subsequent comments.

Comment author: shokwave 13 March 2014 04:25:46PM 0 points [-]

Even given other technological civilisations existing, putting "matter and energy manipulation tops out a little above our current cutting edge" at 5% is way off.

Comment author: ThisSpaceAvailable 16 March 2014 02:29:57AM 1 point [-]

Way off in which direction?

Comment author: CellBioGuy 14 March 2014 02:00:13AM 0 points [-]

There's a lot you can do on the surface of a clement planet, and a lot you can do in a solar system without replicators that eat everything. Also depends on what you mean by 'above'.