Ritalin comments on Rationalist fiction: a Slice of Life IN HELL - Less Wrong

7 Post author: Ritalin 25 March 2014 05:02PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (26)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: shminux 25 March 2014 05:30:20PM *  2 points [-]

This could be an interesting way to showcase rationalist principles, especially those regarding safety and planning, in a perpetual Worst Case Scenario environment. There's ample potential for constant conflict,

Wildbow of the Worm fame describes something like that in Pact. The protagonist is unwillingly thrust into the world where he inherited a karmic debt from previous generations and so

reality is out to get them, this is a constant uphill battle, and even the slightest negligence can have a terrible cost.

The serial is not explicitly "rationalist", but irrational (in that universe) decisions bite him in the rear pretty quickly. And so do rational decisions sometimes. Even your best actions against a hostile universe can only get you so far.

Is this similar to what you had in mind?

Comment author: Ritalin 25 March 2014 06:12:33PM 4 points [-]

Indeed. Although, frankly, what I've seen of Worm so far seems to designate it as very similar to my idea of Hell; every accomplishment is either made moot or cost something irreplaceable and possibly of superior value, every victory is short-lived, every mistake is paid for dearly. Every situation is desperate, every problem urgent. By the time a conflict reaches its resolution, another is at its peak, and two more are right around the corner. Perhaps it's even worse; hardship, instead of building character, corrupts it.

For the characters, it must be like a nightmare they can't wake up from.

Comment author: Protagoras 26 March 2014 12:24:07PM 0 points [-]

Yeah, Worm is pretty bleak. I tend to find that a bit overwhelming at times myself; I like the series because of its other strengths (diverse and interesting characters, intelligent plotting, deep and rich setting) with the oppressive tone being a small strike against it for me.