Snorri comments on Open thread, 9-15 June 2014 - Less Wrong

3 Post author: Tenoke 09 June 2014 01:07PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (239)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: drethelin 09 June 2014 04:38:18PM *  2 points [-]

Your case was kinda simple and condescending. On the other hand I can answer Wright by saying "Phineas Gage"

Comment author: Snorri 09 June 2014 05:49:59PM 0 points [-]

I don't think anyone denies that brain states have a strong influence on conscious experience, which is the only thing that Phineas Gage proved. The real question is how mechanistic matter can create subjective experience. For example, someone who was completely colorblind from birth could never understand what it felt like to see the color green, no matter how much neuroscience that person knew, i.e., you could never convey the sensation of "green" through a layout of a connectome or listing wavelengths of light.

However, this doesn't mean that there must be some magical substance which produces experience, and it does not mean that Whole Brain Emulation and AGI is impossible, which is the hasty conclusion reached by many non-materialists. Rather, it only poses problems for those who say that brain states are the same thing as conscious experience.

Comment author: shware 09 June 2014 06:52:57PM 5 points [-]

For example, someone who was completely colorblind from birth could never understand what it felt like to see the color green, no matter how much neuroscience that person knew, i.e., you could never convey the sensation of "green" through a layout of a connectome or listing wavelengths of light.

The 'colorblind-synesthete'?

Comment author: Manfred 09 June 2014 06:37:46PM *  1 point [-]

Also see orthonormal's posts here (and accompanying discussion). I remember the point being similar to "I might know all about heroin and how I'd respond to it, but taking heroin means that certain neurons release chemicals in ways that I don't have conscious control over, and it e.g. will cause memories to be formed that I could not form normally."

Comment author: jacob_cannell 10 June 2014 07:15:40AM 0 points [-]

The real question is how mechanistic matter can create subjective experience.

Philosophy (which today is mostly a historical field - the study of old speculations) is not the right place to find the answer to this question. Computational neuroscience is.

Rather, it only poses problems for those who say that brain states are the same thing as conscious experience.

The 'problem' is overstated - the mindstate of observing green through information flowing from the retina through multiple layers of visual cortical processing is in a wholly different category than the congenital colorblind's mindstate of thinking about green as an abstract linguistic concept.

The two mindstates are completely different and involve largely unrelated computations in functionally distinct minds.