As gjm summarizes that's not the case. I don't think it should automatically be the case the the people downvoted by Eugene are ineligible for moderator. However having been the candidate of a downvote attack doesn't make you the best person to objectively decide how to punish the next mass downvoter, so it's okay that people downvoted by Eugene score less well on that metric.

I want a moderator who's not a controversial figure and who's trusted to make objective decisions.