katydee comments on Simulate and Defer To More Rational Selves - Less Wrong

125 Post author: BrienneYudkowsky 17 September 2014 06:11PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (112)

You are viewing a single comment's thread.

Comment author: katydee 13 September 2014 05:50:54PM 4 points [-]

This is a line of development that-- while clearly useful-- seems somewhat hacky and unpromising to me. While I agree that this is likely to yield useful benefits in the short run, it strikes me that fixing one's internal structure in order to produce reliably correct external actions without these sorts of hacks seems more promising in terms of long-term growth and skills.

About a year ago, I thought that lucid dreaming was a great path to rationality. While lucid dreaming is a great way to train the skill of noticing confusion, I no longer recommend it to people asking me for advice on rationality practice, because I think you hit the skill ceiling relatively fast and it doesn't particularly lend itself to further development.

I'm worried that this strategy falls prey to the same flaw-- while it's quite effective in the short run, I think that people using these methods will ultimately have to learn the internal solutions anyway if they wish to progress to more advanced domains. Therefore, it makes more sense to me to just start with the internal solutions.

(Of course, if you need rapid skill growth in the short term, this might well be a useful strategy to adopt-- just be aware of the downsides.)

Comment author: [deleted] 19 September 2014 05:12:29AM 1 point [-]

I've been thinking about trying out lucid dreaming. Do you think it's not useful in general, or just in terms of becoming more rational?

Comment author: katydee 19 September 2014 06:03:44AM *  1 point [-]

Hmm, depends on what you mean by useful. I think lucid dreaming is:

a) very fun

b) useful for becoming more rational,, but only in a somewhat limited way-- it can be very good for training noticing confusion but doesn't seem to have a huge amount of potential beyond this.

Comment author: [deleted] 21 September 2014 01:59:45AM *  2 points [-]

By useful, I mean, can I use it to:

  • Practice a speech?

  • Deliberate about a decision with imagined famous people?

  • Get more comfortable around people of high status?