I agree that "independent" poorly characterizes the behaviour of most self-identified "independents", but it doesn't follow that "the polling data on partisan affiliation is worthless". Here comes the ROT-13.

Gur cbyyvat qngn erznva tbbq rivqrapr nobhg cebsrffrq oryvrs & vqragvgl rira vs gurl'er ovnfrq rivqrapr nobhg orunivbhe, naq V gbbx pner gb nfx nobhg frys-vqragvsvpngvba, abg orunivbhe. Fbzrbar ryfr zvtug pbzcynva gung gurl'er zber vagrerfgrq va orunivbhe guna oryvrs, ohg rira gb gurz V guvax gur qngn fubhyq or gryyvat: tvira gung zbfg HF nqhygf frys-vqragvsl nf Erchoyvpna be Qrzbpeng va gur snpr bs n ceb-vaqrcraqrag ovnf, gur cenpgvpny pbapyhfvba gung zbfg HF nqhygf ner cnegvfna whfg trgf nyy gur fgebatre.