The concept learning proposal is basically finished right? Submit it now.
Good point, that makes sense.
I guess "can't choose the right one" wasn't actually my true rejection, rather I'm hesitating because I'm not sure whether this field is actually where my comparative advantage lies, and whether this is the kind of thing that I'd want to be doing. I do fine when it comes to vague philosophizing at the level of my original concept learning paper, but I'm much less certain of my ability to do actual rigorous technical work. Meanwhile I seem to be getting promising feedback of doing well on some other (non-technical) high-impact projects I've been pursuing.
Though I guess I could apply for the first stage of the grants anyway and decide later, since it doesn't commit me to anything yet...
I'm not sure whether this field is actually where my comparative advantage lies.
What else are you considering?
I would advise that's only half the the equation though. You should also weight by how unique that contribution would be. We simply don't have enough people doing AGI work like concept formation. Not to place too much pressure, but if you don't work on this then it's not clear who would. It's an underfunded area academically (hence these grants are a great opportunity), and too long term to be a part of industrial research efforts...
As a follow-on to the recent thread on purchasing research effectively, I thought it'd make sense to post the request for proposals for projects to be funded by Musk's $10M donation. LessWrong's been a place for discussing long-term AI safety and research for quite some time, so I'd be happy to see some applications come out of LW members.
Here's the full Request for Proposals.
If you have questions, feel free to ask them in the comments or to contact me!
Here's the email FLI has been sending around: