FrameBenignly comments on Natural Selection of Government Systems - Less Wrong

5 Post author: cleonid 08 February 2015 06:11PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (56)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: FrameBenignly 09 February 2015 03:11:22AM *  1 point [-]

State and local governments in the US have primary responsibility over education, road construction, utilities, policing, the courts, licensing restrictions, zoning laws, and public transportation. The federal government can and does sometimes overrule them in these areas, but they are mostly left to themselves. Federal government action tends to be restricted towards various welfare programs, foreign policy, and the health care system. I would not describe state and local governments as having little power.

Comment author: cleonid 09 February 2015 12:45:32PM 2 points [-]

State and local governments may have significant spending power, but limited freedom of using it. The central government can very effectively pressure states to comply with its policies by providing or withdrawing federal subsidies (e.g., NCLB). It can also directly veto any politically controversial decision by a state on how to spend its money (e.g., California Proposition 187).

Comment author: asr 09 February 2015 05:55:17AM 0 points [-]

This graph would be more interesting and persuasive with a better caption.