cleonid comments on Natural Selection of Government Systems - Less Wrong

5 Post author: cleonid 08 February 2015 06:11PM

You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.

Comments (56)

You are viewing a single comment's thread. Show more comments above.

Comment author: cleonid 18 February 2015 04:01:25PM 0 points [-]

Violence exists not out of necessity, but basically because we like it.

This is similar to sex and reproduction. Animals reproduce not because they consciously want offspring, but because they enjoy the process itself. Likewise, violence is often enjoyed for its own sake, rather than for its material rewards. However, for humans the invention of contraceptives made it possible to decouple reproduction from sex. Similarly, once violence becomes unnecessary people will still find it enjoyable, but it may be possible to replace the actual violence with surrogates (e.g., sport contests or computer games).

Ceding low means fracturing a country, and people will not like that, because they reify and essentialize their country/government (nationalism).

This is certainly a problem, but are you convinced that it is unsolvable? In Europe, many countries already have strong separatist movements (for instance, Lega Nord in Italy). I am not aware of any popular political movements with the opposite goal (making their countries more centralized).