jacob_cannell comments on Concept Safety: What are concepts for, and how to deal with alien concepts - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (18)
This really is the most realistic scenario for AGI in general, given the generality of the RL architecture. Of course, there are many variations - especially in how the training environment and utility feedback interact.
If we want the AI to do human-ish labor tasks, a humanoid body makes lots of sense. It also makes sense for virtual acting, interacting with humans in general, etc. A virtual humanoid body has many advantages - with instantiation in a physical robot as a special case.
Yep - kindof unavoidable unless somebody releases the first advanced AGI for free. Even then, most people wouldn't invest the time to educate and instill their values.
So say you train the AI to compute a mapping between a sentence in english describing a moral scenario and a corresponding sentiment/utility, how do you translate that into the AI's reward/utility function? You'd need to somehow also map encodings of imagined moral scenarios back and forth between encodings of observation histories.
Of course, "gradually training the AGI's values through an extended childhood" gets tricky if it turns out that there's a hard takeoff.
I was thinking that the task of training the AI to classify human judgments would then lead to it building up a model of human values, similar to the way that training a system to do word prediction builds up a language / world model. You make a good point of the need to then ground those values further; I haven't really thought about that part.
Yes. Once you get the AGI up to roughly human child level, presumably autodidactic learning could takeover. Reading and understanding text on the internet is a specific key activity that could likely be sped up by a large factor.
So - then we need ways to speed up human interaction and supervision to match.