jacob_cannell comments on Resolving the Fermi Paradox: New Directions - Less Wrong
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
You are viewing a comment permalink. View the original post to see all comments and the full post content.
Comments (58)
And I was trying to illustrate that there's more to life than considering one cold brain in isolation in the void without asking any questions about what else all that free energy could be used for.
A Dyson sphere helps with moving matter around, potentially with elemental conversion, and with cooling. If nothing else, if the ambient energy of the star is a big problem, you can use it to redirect the energy elsewhere away from your cold brains.
Exponential growth. I think Sandberg's calculated you can build a Dyson sphere in a century, apropos of KIC 8462852's oddly gradual dimming. And you hardly need to finish it before you get any benefits.
You say 'may', but that seems really likely. After all, what 'complex set of unknowns' will be so fine-tuned that the answer will, for all civilizations, be 0 rather than some astronomically large number? This is the heart of your argument! You need to show this, not handwave it! You cannot show that this resolves the Fermi paradox unless you make a solid case that cold brains will find harnessing solar systems' energy and matter totally useless! As it stands, this article reads like '1. reversible computing is awesome 2. ??? 3. no expansion, hence, transcension 4. Fermi paradox solved!' No, it's not. Stop handwaving and show that more cold brains are not better, that there are zero uses for all the stellar energy and mass, and there won't be any meaningful colonization or stellar engineering.
Which is a highly dubious case, of course.
I don't see why the usual infrared argument doesn't apply to them or KIC 8462852.
If by infrared argument, you refer to the idea that a dyson swarm should radiate in the infrared, this is probably wrong. This relies on the assumption that the alien civ operates at earth temp of 300K or so. As you reduce that temp down to 3K, the excess radiation diminishes to something indistinguishable to the CMB, so we can't detect large cold structures that way. For the reasons discussed earlier, non-zero operating temp would only be useful during initial construction phases, whereas near-zero temp is preferred in the long term. The fact that KIC 8462852 has no infrared excess makes it more interesting, not less.